top of page

How to check a brain claim yourself

Most people cannot tell a research finding from a confident sentence, and that is how this field earned its reputation. Here is the test I use. Point it at my work as readily as anyone else's.

Ask what the claim would look like if it were false. A real finding has edges: conditions where it does not hold, a population it was measured in, a size worth reporting. "Stress narrows what a child can access" comes with all of that attached. "We only use ten percent of our brains" has none of it, which is how it survived for decades without ever being true.

Then ask who benefits from you believing it. That is not a cynical question. It is the one that keeps me honest about my own vocabulary, which is why the terms I invented are labelled as mine on this page rather than dressed up as neuroscience.

One more, and it is the hardest. Ask whether the claim changes what you would do on Monday. Plenty of true neuroscience has no classroom implication at all, and plenty of what gets sold as brain-based is a real finding stretched several steps past what it can carry.

If a claim passes all three, it is probably worth your time. If it fails the first one, nothing else matters.

bottom of page