Is It Defiance or Dysregulation? How to Tell the Difference
A student does not start the next task. You remind them. You wait. You remind again, and still nothing. At home, your child hears "shoes on" for the fourth time and throws one down the hall.
It is easy to think, "They are refusing." Sometimes that is true. More often, what looks like defiance is a brain that cannot reach what it needs in that moment. From the outside the two look almost the same, and they need very different responses.
What the two have in common
Both show up as a child who is not doing what was asked. Crossed arms. A notebook quietly closed. A sharp reply, or no reply at all.
The difference is underneath. Defiance is a choice made by a brain that still has access to its thinking. Dysregulation is a state where the nervous system is stressed or flooded enough that reasoning, memory and impulse control drop. A dysregulated child is not refusing to think clearly. In that moment, they cannot.
I said "calm down" for years before I understood why it almost never worked. "Calm down" asks a dysregulated brain to do the one thing it currently cannot do. A bigger consequence asks the same thing, louder.
What is happening in the brain
As emotional intensity rises, access to thinking falls. When stress or confusion sets in, the amygdala scans for threat and the prefrontal cortex, the part of the brain responsible for reasoning and problem-solving, can go offline. Working memory shrinks, and a direction slips away before the child can use it.
So a child can know the expectation and have the skill, and still not be able to reach either one.
This also starts earlier than most of us notice. Attention drifts and small mistakes pile up well before anyone would call it a behavior problem. By the time you see the behavior, it has usually been building for a while.
Three questions to ask before you correct
Before you correct the behavior, get curious about the demand.
Is the task clear? If the child did not take in the direction, repeating it the same way will not help. Say it differently, or show it.
Is the first step manageable? Starting a task takes more than knowing what to do. A child has to hold the directions in mind, organize the steps and manage frustration before they can begin.
Is the child regulated enough to engage? If not, no amount of explaining will land yet. Regulation comes first.
If the answer to all three is yes and the child still will not move, you may be looking at a choice. That deserves a response too. Even then, it is worth asking what the behavior is telling you.
Resistance is information too
Resistance is not all the same. In the Neuroeducation Framework I describe three levels of resistance, and each level points to a different kind of support. Some children need a different way into the task. Others are missing a skill the task depends on.
None of these is solved by saying the same thing louder.
What to do in the moment
Try subtracting instead of adding.
Use fewer words. Give one step, then stop talking.
Wait ten seconds. The quiet is not giving in.
If they start, the amount you were asking them to hold was the problem. Keep your directions short.
If they still cannot start, do the first step beside them, or help them settle before you ask again.
A steady sentence helps more than a sharp one: "I am right here. We will figure this out." Then teach.
This does not lower the bar
Understanding what drives a behavior is different from excusing it. The expectation does not move. The approach does. A regulated child can work toward a high expectation, and a dysregulated child cannot meet any expectation until their brain is back online. The conversation you want to have about the behavior needs a child who can take part in it, and regulation is how you get one.
Keep learning
Go deeper. The Neuroeducation Framework lays out the three levels of resistance and the six levels of emotional response, with what helps at each one.
Dysregulation and behavior is communication in the Neuroeducation Glossary
The 12 Neuroeducation Concepts, especially Emotional Response Impacts Performance
For parents: Why Does My Child Do That?
Free guide: 5 Things Every Adult Should Know About the Brain. Plain-language brain science for teachers and parents. Get the free guide
Comments